cakes

Making gluten free cakes that actually taste good since 2012. All of our cakes are round, 3 layered cakes, and they’re ready to party.

http://www.sweettheorybakingco.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/cakes-hero-1.png
http://www.sweettheorybakingco.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/specialty-cakes-whisk.png

Specialty
Cakes

Our favorite cakes to make all the time! Perfect combinations, great for all occasions.

http://www.sweettheorybakingco.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/custom-cakes-spatula.png

Custom
Cakes

Have something specific in mind? Choose from our list of flavors and we’ll whip up something great!

Specialty Cakes

6 in/$45 · 8 in/$60 · 10 in/$75
Stretch Pants Cake

Chocolate cake, vanilla frosting, chocolate chip cookies, caramel and chocolate drizzle.

Cinnamon Roll Cake

Snickerdoodle cake, cinnamon roll pieces, cinnamon drizzle
*No GF option

http://www.sweettheorybakingco.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/specialty-cakes-cake-strawberry-768x661.png
So Fudging Good Cake

2 layer chocolate cake, 1 layer brownie, chocolate sunbutter frosting, chocolate chips, chocolate and caramel drizzle

Yoga Pants Cake

Vanilla cake, vanilla frosting, brownie, brownie crumbles, caramel

http://www.sweettheorybakingco.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/custom-cakes-cake-table.png

Custom Cakes

cake flavors

Vanilla, Chocolate, Banana, Lemon, Coconut, Mexican Chocolate, Snickerdoodle, Orange, Vanilla Lavender, Carrot, Chocolate Lavender, Chai, Lemon Poppy, Maple, Marble, Spice, Strawberry, Pumpkin (seasonal), Gingerbread (seasonal)

frostings

Vanilla, Chocolate, Lemon, Mexican Chocolate, Salted Caramel, Espresso, Strawberry, Maple, Dreamsicle, Sunbutter, Mint

add-ons (+ $6-10 )

Brownie crumbles, Chocolate chip cookies, Ganache, Caramel, Berries

6 Inch

$35

Serves 8-12

8 Inch

$50

Serves 12-16

10 Inch

$65

Serves 16-20

COVID-19 Update

Due to the current pandemic, our business operations are as follows: We are available for call in/curbside pick up orders (check Instagram for daily flavor postings). Contact us at 904-387-1001 or 904-208-0468. We are currently allowing 2 people in our shop at a time to take treats to-go (no indoor dining available). We are limiting our hours of operation for the time being, Wed – Fri 8:30 – 4, Sat/Sun 10 – 4. Thank you for your support during this time!